Welcome to Roya News, stay informed with the most important news at your fingertips.

Photo credit: Zachary Schulman.

1
Image 1 from gallery

Mamdani defends October 7 remarks criticizing 'Israel'

Listen to this story:
0:00

Note: AI technology was used to generate this article’s audio.

Published :  
20/11/2026 16:18|
  • Mamdani defended condemning both Hamas and 'Israel' in one statement at the DealBook Summit rejecting calls for separate statements
  • He cited attending an October 7 vigil despite protests, arguing his "politics of universality" demands opposing all international law violations 
  • Mamdani vowed to combat all bigotry while serving every New Yorker 

New York City Mayor Zohran Kwame Mamdani defended his public framing of the October 7 attacks and the war in Gaza during a pointed exchange with New York Times columnist Andrew Ross Sorkin at the DealBook Summit, arguing that his political philosophy demands mourning all victims and opposing violations of international law equally.

During the onstage interview, Sorkin pressed Mamdani on the language he uses regarding Israel and Palestine and its impact on Jewish New Yorkers.

Sorkin pointed specifically to Mamdani’s October 7 statement, noting that while it condemned Hamas, the majority of its words were spent criticizing 'Israel', a balance that drew pushback from Jewish leaders, including the head of the Reform Jewish movement and a rabbi who asked whether the community could "just have one day" of unreserved mourning.

Sorkin asked whether Mamdani would ever consider issuing a statement solely condemning the October 7 attacks on the day itself, and waiting until October 8 to criticize the 'Israeli' government's actions.

Mamdani pushed back, arguing that focusing solely on the wording of his written statement omitted his physical presence alongside grieving New Yorkers.

He noted that on the night of October 7, he attended a vigil for those allegedly killed in the attacks -just as he had the previous year- even though he was protested while attending.

"My politics is one that believes that there has to be room to mourn everyone," Mamdani said, adding that his statement and attendance were meant to make clear that he will oppose violations of international law "no matter who commits them and who conducts them".

While calling the October 7 attacks a "horrific war crime," Mamdani stated that the day has simultaneously been used by the 'Israeli' government as a justification for what he described as a "genocide of Palestinians".

"It is in that day that it is important, like in any day, to mourn the totality of its impact," he explained, attributing his refusal to separate the two messages to a "politics of universality" that extends the same human rights values to everyone.

At the same time, Mamdani forcefully addressed Sorkin’s citation of data showing that anti-Jewish incidents account for roughly 53 percent of hate crimes in New York City.

Mamdani noted that while Jewish residents make up between 10 and 12 percent of the city's population, they represent more than half of all hate crime victims, a disparity he called "unacceptable".

Expressing pride in serving as mayor of "the most Jewish city in the United States of America," Mamdani stressed that much of New York's identity is tied to its Jewish heritage and vowed to "root out antisemitism" alongside any other form of bigotry.

He acknowledged that many Jewish New Yorkers, as well as residents of other faiths or no faith, strongly disagree with his views on 'Israel' and Palestine, but insisted those differences would not affect his governance.

"My job is to still deliver for them as well, and to deliver them the best possible city, because at the end of the day, they live in this city," Mamdani said.